NOW EXPERIENCING:Rusty Nail cocktail recipe
Cocktails|Dry|Whisk(e)y|Liqueurs

Rusty Nail cocktail recipe

total time 2 MINS | serves 1 | standard drinks per serve 1.9 approx.

Read time 4 Mins

Posted 09 Feb 2023

By
Dan’s Daily


A classic Rusty Nail cocktail in a heavy rocks glass with a large ice cube and a lemon twist garnish.

Beyond the classic: Modern twists on the whisky staple.

About the cocktail

The Rusty Nail is thought to have made its first public appearance in 1937, but it wasn’t until the 1960s that it was officially christened, thanks to the endorsement of the then-chairwoman of Drambuie. The origin of the Rusty Nail name is still unknown; a popular theory is that the first version was stirred with a rusty nail, but this may be a reference to the colour of the rusty nails that held cases of Drambuie together, or the colour of the drink. Name aside, the cocktail proved popular with the notorious Rat Pack, who catapulted the Rusty Nail to fame across the world.

As for what to expect from the Rusty Nail cocktail, this is a treat for whisky fans – its beauty lying in its simplicity. By mixing whisky with a whisky liqueur, the result is an approachable cocktail with a touch of sweetness that still lets the whisky shine.  

Watch: How to make a Rusty Nail

Rusty Nail cocktail recipe ingredients

  • 45mL Scotch whisky
  • 15mL whisky liqueur
  • Garnish: lemon peel

Method

  1. Combine all ingredients in a tumbler over ice
  2. Stir to combine ingredients
  3. Garnish with a lemon peel

Dan’s top tips

The ratio for a Rusty Nail comes down to personal preference. Some like it half-half, many prefer it three-parts Scotch to one-part liqueur. Add more Scotch if you're finding yours too sweet, and add more liqueur if there’s too much of a kick. Once you find the right ratio, you'll swear by it.

Other than that, there is not a lot to mess up with this drink – two ingredients and a citrus twist to finish, and you have yourself a sophisticated sipper. 

Frequently asked questions (FAQs)
  1. How do you make a Rusty Nail that isn't too sweet?
    If you're finding your Rusty Nail a little too sweet, add a little more Scotch, but be aware that the ABV of the cocktail will increase.

  2. What is the best Australian whisky for a Rusty Nail cocktail?
    When it comes to Australia whisky, we love brands like Starward, Archie Rose, Morris and Lark. 

  3. Can I get Rusty Nail cocktail ingredients delivered at my home?
    Yes, you can get everything you need to make a Rusty Nail delivered to your door from Dan Murphy's. If same-day delivery isn't an option, you can also place a click and collect order and pick it up from your local store.

  4. Why is the Rusty Nail called a two-ingredient masterpiece?
    A Rusty Nail is called a two-ingredient masterpiece because it calls for just two ingredients – Scotch whisky and whisky liqueur.