NOW EXPERIENCING:Good Measure
Tuesday: 8:00 AM – 11:00 PM
Phone
No phone
Instagram
@goodmeasuremelbourne

Read time 4 Mins

Posted 02 Mar 2023

By
Ellen Fraser


A progressive cocktail spot on Lygon Street with a throwback aesthetic and inventive drinks – think Cherry Ripe Old Fashioneds and Triple-Chilli Margaritas – in a league of their own.

Why you go

Lygon Street is lucky to have Good Measure, a coffee-to-cocktail spot that’s unlike anything else in the area. When it launched in late 2021, it was a sun-drenched daytime diner doing Code Black coffee, cheesecake and bougie hot dogs. A few months later, things really kicked off as the after-dark offering emerged, delivering cocktails of a calibre you’d previously have had to schlep to the city or Fitzroy for.

The drinks list changes often. Cocktails are made with a laser-focus on seasonality and sustainability – a DIY ethos sees the team striving to use every element of each ingredient. Plum pits might go into the creation of a punchy Blood Plum Margarita, banana skins could be infused into a whisky-based number, and leftover sweet cinnamon babka brioche is turned into a house signature. 

There are more cocktails on tap alongside sake from Melbourne Sake Co, low-touch wine by small operations such as Dirty Black Denim and Konpira Maru, brews from as nearby as Hop Nation and Garage Project, and as far away as Guinness, and kombucha, rhubarb lemonade, and nitro coffee (a frothy, nitrogen-infused cold brew) on the non-alcoholic front.

Why you stayBrown on brown on brown – it’s a bold choice for an interior colour scheme. But with light pouring in through floor-to-ceiling front windows, exposed wooden beams, and a retro record player spinning anything from Dire Straits to 1950s jazz, the earth-toned space gives off a warm, immediately familiar feel. The fit-out is by architecture firm We are Humble, which took inspiration from neighbourhood cafes and coffee shops in Japan and Korea to reimagine the former bike shop, giving it a terracotta-tiled back bar, polished wooden floors, and tabletops the colour of proper sourdough bread.
What drink to orderThe go-to is undoubtedly the buttery clarified Babka Milk Punch, made using a technique that turns creamy drinks clear through a process of curdling and straining. Co-owner Max Allison borrowed it from Darren Leaney, former bar manager at swish pizzeria Capitano, whose Tiramisù Milk Punch attracted a far-reaching fanbase. To make his version, Max infuses milk with Spitz's Bakehouse babka left over from the daytime menu, brings on the curdle with a little lemon juice, then mirrors the babka’s genetic make-up by adding brown-butter whisky, cinnamon whisky and pecan syrup (all made in-house). The result is a creamy, buttery, lightly spiced concoction that’s as translucent as the glass it’s served in. 
What to pair it withThe snack selection is heaven for the decision-phobic, equal parts short and shareable. Think tall, puffy focaccia you’ll be almost sorry to squish and swipe through house-made hummus, plus humongous green olives, cheese from all-Aussie cheese shop Ripe, and cured meats and pickles with big hunks of warm bread on the side. 
Why we love itWhile there’s some complexity going on behind the scenes, you won’t be handed a lengthy novel of a menu or told your drink’s origin story (unless you ask). A board lists simple descriptions – a Triple-Chilli Margarita, a Cherry Ripe Old Fashioned, a Cumquat Negroni, a Blood Orange and Macadamia Martini – all sharing DNA with a classic, but given a firm creative nudge. A Good Measure White Russian (a drink typically made with vodka, Kahlua and cream) still brings together something creamy and something caffeinated, but here that means yoghurt-washed Scotch whisky and house bergamot liqueur.  
Regular's tipBy day, plant yourself at the wraparound timber bench by the front window and bask in all that abundant natural light. By night, the best seat in the house is along the wood-panelled bar, where sprightly pot plants peek down alongside framed prints and angular vases. If you’re in a group, the back courtyard is your friend. 
Don't leave withoutThe must-try during daylight hours is the Mont Blanc, a non-alcoholic pick-me-up made with a base of sweet, cold filter coffee topped with a St David Dairy cream float. A light dusting of finely shaved nutmeg and orange zest rounds the whole thing out with a little spice and zing.