NOW EXPERIENCING:Second Serve cocktail recipe
Cocktails|Summer|Aperitifs & Vermouth|Other

Second Serve cocktail recipe

total time 3 MINS | serves 1 | standard drinks per serve 0.9 approx.

Read time 2 Mins

Posted 13 May 2024

By
James Fisher


The Second Serve is a bitter-sweet citrusy cocktail

A surprising – and serious – Spritz with bitter-sweet, citrusy oomph.

About the cocktail

Tennis fans will spot the similarities between Second Serve and the new-generation tour leaders. Fino sherry and Amaro Montenegro. Spain and Italy. Carlos Alcaraz and Jannik Sinner. On the court, it’s clash of the titans. In the glass, it’s an unlikely, but perfectly balanced, doubles pairing. At 0.9 standard drinks, a second Second Serve may not be out of the question, especially, when the final goes to a fifth set.

Second Serve was created by Dan Greenbaum at the beloved venue Attaboy in New York, and inspired by Rome With a View, a cocktail created at Milk & Honey, the bar that originally occupied the Attaboy space. Curiously, Rome With a View was inspired by Triumph of Pompeii, which in turn was inspired by Rome is Burning. Where are we going with this? Originality doesn’t matter when the cocktails are this good.

Attaboy has no menu, and they serve bespoke, bartender’s choice cocktails according to the patron’s preferred base spirit. Second Serve is ideal for this format. The range of flavour profiles available from fino sherry and Amaro Montenegro is diverse, and they will all blend and contrast differently, allowing you to shape the cocktail to suit any palate.

Second Serve is a well-rounded percentage player – even as a bubbly aperitivo, it isn’t trying to hit an ace. The soda and fresh lime make it refreshing, while the sherry and amaro deliver complexity to taste. Our version is dry and clean, with a carefully balanced bitter-sweet profile, and some citrusy oomph for good measure. There’s a saying in tennis, ‘you’re only as good as your second serve’.

The Second Serve cocktail in a tall glass
Pouring the Second Serve

Ingredients

  • 30mL fino sherry
  • 30mL Amaro Montenegro
  • 30mL fresh lime juice
  • 20mL sugar syrup
  • 40mL soda water (or to top, to your liking)
  • Glass: highball
  • Garnish: orange slice

Method

  1. Add all ingredients to a cocktail shaker
  2. Add cubed ice, and give it a short, sharp shake
  3. Carefully strain into a chilled glass
  4. Add cubed ice, top with soda, then carefully stir
  5. Garnish with an orange slice

Dan’s top tips

What’s the easiest way to tweak a Spritz? Adjust the volume of whatever’s doing the spritzing. For Second Serve, add more, or less, soda water to enhance, or mellow, the flavour profile. Simple.

Don’t know a fino from an oloroso? We’ve created an in-depth guide to sherry to help answer all your questions.

And if you’ve ever wondered, what actually is an amaro? We’ve got you covered there, too, with everything you need to know about this classic digestive.

image credits: Shelley Horan (photography), Bridget Wald (stylist).