NOW EXPERIENCING:Hot Cross Bun cocktail recipe
Cocktails|Night cap|Winter|Whisk(e)y

Hot Cross Bun cocktail recipe

total time 2 MINS | serves 1 | standard drinks per serve 1.6 approx.

Read time 3 Mins

Posted 14 Mar 2024

By
Lulu Morris


Have your hot cross bun and drink it too with this delightfully sweet and golden whiskey cocktail in honour of our favourite Easter carb.

About the cocktail

What would trashy news websites moan about if we didn’t have the early resurgence of hot cross buns every year? The weather? The staggering cost of living? Nah, from Christmas ’til Easter (and usually beyond) it’s the hottest topic of conversation. But despite the annual media outrage, we reckon everyone’s kind of glad the mince pie months have lapsed. After all, wouldn’t you rather a nice hot, sticky, honey-gold bun than a cold crumbly mess? So, off the back of the hot cross bun flurry (and whether you’re pro early buns or not), we’ve created a Hot Cross Bun Cocktail that is not only bloody delicious, but also wonderfully complex.

Before we get into the nitty-gritty of the cocktail, let’s have a squiz at when these cinnamony, nutmeg, and raisiny breads first came about. You’ve heard the old 19th-century nursery rhyme – “Hot cross buns, hot cross buns, one a penny, two a penny, hot cross buns” – but did you know these little honey-hued goodies have been around for much longer? The Saxons ate crossed buns to honour Eostre the goddess of spring and light, while druids were known to celebrate similar events with buns, as were the Phoenicians. And the Greeks and Romans ate their buns marked with crosses in honour of Diana, goddess of the hunt and the moon. You can actually see proof of these little Roman buns in the ruins of Pompeii. So, to sum up, hot cross buns have been popular forever, and their reappearance every year should be something to celebrate. After all, they’ve outlived quite a few trends over the years (remember cronuts?).

Creating a drinkable version of our centuries-old carb was a tall order, but we think we’ve done a pretty good job. This recipe does require you to make a hot cross bun syrup, but fear not, it’s super easy to make. It’s essentially golden syrup, water, orange zest, a cinnamon quill and allspice. The syrup does all the heavy lifting in this cocktail, so it’s important to get the measurements right. The sweet spice of the syrup pairs perfectly with the whiskey, while the addition of egg (or cream, if you’re not an egg-in-cocktails person) mellows the sweetness slightly and gives it a bit of flair.

Keen to have your hot cross bun and drink it too? Get stuck into our recipe and top tips below.

A glass of Hot Cross Bun cocktail
The Hot Cross Bun cocktail with two hot cross buns

Ingredients: Hot cross bun syrup

  • ½ cup golden syrup
  • 50mL water
  • zest of half an orange
  • 1 cinnamon quill, cracked 
  • ½ teaspoon allspice

Ingredients: Hot Cross Bun cocktail

  • 50mL whiskey
  • 20mL hot cross bun syrup (see above)
  • 1 whole egg (or replace with 30mL of cream)
  • Glass: stemless wine glass, fine coffee or tea cup, or goblet
  • Garnish: cinnamon powder

Method: Hot cross bun syrup

  1. Place all syrup ingredients into a small saucepan on a low heat and slowly bring to a gentle simmer, stirring constantly to incorporate ingredients and prevent burning
  2. Allow to simmer for one minute then remove from heat
  3. Let it steep for a minimum of three hours, then strain to remove all solids once cool
  4. Store in a sealed container in the fridge for up to two weeks

Method: Hot Cross Bun cocktail

  1. If using egg, add all ingredients to a cocktail shaker and, without ice, shake hard to emulsify
  2. Add ice and shake hard again (if using cream instead of egg, you can skip the first step and go straight to shaking all ingredients with ice)
  3. Double strain into your chosen vessel
  4. Garnish with a light dusting of cinnamon powder

Dan’s top tips

As with all cocktails served without ice, we need to ensure our glass is nice and frosty before we pour our cocktail in. So, before you start shaking, or even making your syrup, chuck your chosen glassware in the freezer.

Because there is a homemade syrup element to this cocktail, you’ll need to start prepping the day before (or morning of) to ensure your syrup is ready to go for your Hot Cross Bun cocktail. If it is still hot or hasn’t steeped for three hours (minimum), you’ll end up cooking the egg and be left with a weird curdled whisky puddle. Not good.

Lastly, a word on the egg whites. If the idea of egg in a cocktail makes you feel a little queasy, we’ve provided a cream alternative. That said, the whole egg really does add a texture and smoothness that’s unparalleled, so try it out if it works with your diet.

image credits: Charlie Hawks (photography), Bridget Wald (styling).