NOW EXPERIENCING:Toddy Shop

Read time 3 Mins

Posted 04 Mar 2024

By
Pat Nourse


This tiny Indian bar and diner packs a flavour punch.

Mischa Tropp is behind Collingwood's new Toddy Shop
Why you go

It’s all about the toddy. We’ve seen plenty of specialist bars on the rise in recent years – places that are all about tequila, rum, gin, even amari. But no one else does toddy. Or at least no one in Australia that we know of. It’s the centrepiece of the vision of Mischa Tropp, a chef and restaurateur best known in Melbourne for the food he cooked at The Rochester Hotel, just a few blocks away on Johnston Street. The residency at The Rochey, and subsequent gigs at Avani Winery and Elsie’s restaurant, were a showcase for his exploration of the Keralan part of his heritage. Kerala is a state in India that runs down the western side of the nation’s southern tip, facing the Arabian Sea, not far from Sri Lanka. “There used to be a big spice trade with Europe; cardamom, black pepper, turmeric, chillies. That has a big effect on the cuisine,” Mischa told SBS Food back in 2018 when he was still at The Rochey. “There’s also a lot of coconut, fish and seafood. It’s quite a tropical cuisine. You’d associate it more with Sri Lankan cuisine than north Indian food.”

Toddy Shop, or to give it its full name, Toddy Shop by Marthanden Hotel, is the culmination of him trying out different platforms for sharing more about Kerala – a tiny, potent, very focused little venture that packs a punch. Mischa calls it a South Indian refreshment bar, and it’s definitely that. Home-style Keralan food, paired with wine, beer and cocktails is the name of the game. Oh, and toddy. Let’s not forget the toddy.

Don’t leave withoutAt this point it might be useful to talk about what toddy actually is. First up: it’s not the same as a Hot Toddy – that’s a cocktail made with a dark spirit served hot, typically with honey and lemon, maybe some spices. Delicious, but not the toddy in question. The toddy here is a palm wine, the fermented sap of a palm tree. It’s common to Africa, parts of the Pacific, Southeast Asia, and, perhaps most particularly, to South Asia. It typically lands at about 4% alcohol, so it’s much closer to the strength of a beer than a grape wine. Jac Millar, the brand served at Toddy Shop, is made in Jaffna in Sri Lanka, exclusively from the tap of palmyra trees. It’s naturally fermented, with no added sugar, preservatives or water – if you like your bevs made with minimal intervention, toddy is where it’s at. Poured from the opaque bottle, it’s milky, gently sour, refreshing and delicious. So: don’t leave without trying the toddy.
Why you stayThere’s really nothing like Toddy Shop in town. Even if, heaven forbid, you don’t try the toddy, the pleasure of eating this kind of South Indian food in tight, chic operation like this is something you don’t see much of in Australia today. Mischa is a savvy operator, but he also looks like he’s having a really good time, and it’s easy to get caught up in that energy.
A selection of dishes at Toddy Shop in Melbourne
Enjoy the food at Toddy Shop
What drink to orderToddy! But if palm wine, for some reason, isn’t your thing, there’s plenty more to tempt you. Something stiffer? The house Bengali Martini has your name on it: vodka infused with saffron and garnished with a maraschino cherry. Spicy Marg? The Toddy Shop version comes with the benefit of added mango. And those South Asian flavours keep on popping, with spiced rum powering the Espresso Martini, and black pepper spicing up the Thallasary Paloma in with the tequila, pink grapefruit and lime. Kingfisher flies the flag for Indian-made beers, alongside Victoria’s Two Rupees lager and the now ubiquitous Heaps Normal Quiet XPA. Softs are thoughtful: an Indian lemonade, and spiced Darjeeling iced tea, plus two choices of NON. The wine list is tight: a sparkling, two whites, two rosés, an orange and two reds. But when you look at the names involved – the rosé is from superb Mornington producers Avani, while Geelong legends Lethbridge provide the pinot – it’s clear that the list is short because it’s focused, not because it’s an afterthought. (Also: this place is tiny, so there’s almost certainly no room for boxes and boxes of wine.)
What to pair it withThe menu is also not your usual deal. There’s not really a division between entrées and main courses, and nor are there desserts. You could call it a small-plates place, but it might be more accurate to just say plates. The printed menu lists the vegetable staples and sides – kadala, for instance, the brown coconut curry of chickpeas and mustard seed, or the excellent turmeric-stained cabbage thoran, a nicely scorchy stir-fry fragrant with curry leaf and coconut – while the proteins are on a specials board that changes each week. “Beef roast” is nuggets of meat and tomato in a thin gravy spiced with garam masala and Kashmiri chilli, while the moilee is a soupy yellow curry laden with prawns, peppers and black pepper. The rice is not the Australian-Indian restaurant standard, either – those plump grains are matta, a polished Keralan red rice. Speaking of sides, don’t snooze on the parotta – a scrunchy, golden, flaky swatch of bread is totally necessary for mopping up the most of this goodness.
Dishes served up at Toddy Shop in Collingwood, Melbourne
Regular’s tipIt’s worth underscoring that Toddy Shop is not a big place. Two (small) rooms, one with a clutch of (small) tables, one with (very small) space to stand and have a drink. It also doesn’t take bookings. It’s a good idea to plan around this: you don’t want to go with more than a couple of people, and if standing in line is not your idea of a good time, come for lunch, when things are usually less hectic. And make sure you have a toddy.