NOW EXPERIENCING:Toffee Negroni cocktail recipe
Cocktails|Wine based|Entertaining|Rum

Toffee Negroni cocktail recipe

total time 5 MINS | serves 1 | standard drinks per serve 1.6 approx.

Read time 2 Mins

Posted 04 Mar 2026

By
Evan Jones


The Toffee Negroni is an easy, sweet variation on the classic Negroni cocktail

A sweeter style of Negroni? Sign us up.

About the cocktail

The Negroni might be one of the most popular cocktails in the world, but it can still be a bit of an acquired taste. The simple classic puts the bitter in bittersweet, thanks to its ingredients like Campari and vermouth, which can be a touch too bold for some of us. So, for anyone looking for a sweeter, richer alternative that still hits those same Negroni notes, meet the Toffee Negroni. And, yes – it does taste just like toffee.

Coming from American cocktail legend Lynnette Marrero, the Toffee Negroni follows the same basic formula as the classic original – just with some sweet substitutions. Dark rum, with its brown sugar richness, replaces the botanical notes of gin. Amontillado sherry brings nuttiness in place of the herbaceous, slightly astringent rosso vermouth. And where Campari wears its bitterness with pride, here Aperol offers a softer, sweeter alternative.

Besides offering a toffee-flavoured introduction to the world of Negronis, the thing we love most about this Negroni variation is that it fills a gap in our lives. The bittersweet original is a perfect aperitif (meaning pre-dinner, usually), but the subtle sweetness and extra richness makes the Toffee Negroni a real after-dinner treat, too. We can see this served with an espresso and biscotti on the side, letting us ride the after-dinner wave of relaxed conversation. Or go right ahead and drink it before dinner like the classic – don’t let us hem you in.

Garnish the Toffee Negroni with orange peel
The Toffee Negroni is a sweeter twist on this classic cocktail

Ingredients

  • 30mL dark rum
  • 30mL amontillado sherry
  • 30mL Aperol
  • Glass: rocks
  • Garnish: orange peel

Method

  1. Add all ingredients to a mixing glass with ice
  2. Stir until it’s well chilled and diluted
  3. Strain the drink into a glass over a large ice cube
  4. Garnish with the orange peel

Dan’s top tips

  • The Negroni is a simple cocktail, which means that quality ingredients make a big difference. For our Toffee Negroni, the first port of call is finding a nice rum. Here, our cocktail experts recommend a pot-still rum (like Appleton Estate) or a solera-style rum (like Ron Zacapa). These are usually richer, more full-bodied styles that bring those burnt sugar flavours that will really deliver on the toffee aspect of the cocktail. Whatever you can find, though, it really should be a dark rum – white or gold won’t work as well here.
  • The other thing to find is amontillado sherry, a dry-ish style that’s aged, which develops some hazelnut-like flavours. Ideally, you want a decent quality amontillado, since it will really make a big difference. Avoid the sweeter styles of sherry like oloroso or Pedro Ximenez, unless you’re set on going for a full-on sweetness.
Frequently asked questions (FAQs)
  1. What is the difference between a Negroni and a Toffee Negroni?
    While they share a similar method and name, there are some important differences between the classic Negroni and Toffee Negroni. The Negroni is made with gin, vermouth and Campari, while a Toffee Negroni uses dark rum, amontillado sherry and Aperol.

  2. What makes the Toffee Negroni taste sweet?
    Dark rum usually retains a little sweetness (rum is made from sugarcane, after all) and flavours we associate with sweetness, like brown sugar and caramel. Amontillado sherry is usually quite dry, but its nuttiness helps give the impression of sweetness here.
     

  3. What is amontillado sherry?
    Amontillado is a variety of sherry, dark in colour (but not as dark as oloroso) and aged in oak barrels. It’s nutty and complex.