NOW EXPERIENCING:Lost Plane cocktail recipe
Cocktails|Night cap|Rum|Entertaining

Lost Plane cocktail recipe

total time 3 MINS | serves 1 | standard drinks per serve 1.5 approx.

Read time 2 Mins

Posted 10 Jun 2024

By
James Fisher


 A dark rum based cocktail, the Lost Plane

Seeking a vibrant aperitivo with a dark rum core? This is your boarding call.

About the cocktail

Despite its name, you’ll be relieved to know that Lost Plane is a remarkably easy cocktail to land. Built of equal parts rum, Aperol, amaro and fresh lemon juice, all it requires further is a dash of sugar syrup. Give it some turbulence (that’s pilot for ‘shake with ice’), pour and enjoy. All that’s left to do is practise your ‘this is your captain speaking’ routine.

Lost Plane, created by Emily Gosling of Gosling’s Black Seal Rum, is a riff on Australian bartender Sam Ross’ contemporary classic the Paper Plane. Sam first made the Paper Plane at Chicago’s The Violet Hour in 2005, a few years after he invented the Penicillin at New York’s Milk & Honey.

The original Paper Plane calls for bourbon, whereas Lost Plane favours dark rum, specifically, the Bermudan Gosling’s Black Seal Rum. In case the altitude is making this hard to follow, the name Lost Plane is a clever play on the hero spirit's origin amid the infamous Bermuda triangle.

Lost Plane’s use of Gosling’s Black Seal Rum broadens the Paper Plane into a subtly richer cocktail, while also bringing the amaro to the fore. Speaking of amaro, for more bitterness, and sweetness, the Lost opts for Amaro Montenegro, over the Paper’s Nonino, which is fortuitous since we find Montenegro’s wormwood notes to be the perfect match for Aperol’s grapefruit bitterness.

Now, please take a moment to review the safety card in the seat pocket in front of you – that’s flight attendant for ‘read on for our top tips’ – and once again, thank you for choosing Dan’s Daily.

The Lost Plane features dark rum, Aperol and amaro
Garnish the Lost Plane with lemon zest

Ingredients

  • 25mL dark rum
  • 25mL Aperol
  • 25mL amaro (e.g. Montenegro – see notes for more)
  • 25mL fresh lemon juice
  • 5mL sugar syrup
  • Glass: coupe or Nick and Nora
  • Garnish: lemon zest

Method

  1. Add all ingredients to a cocktail shaker
  2. Add cubed ice, and shake until the outside of the tin is frosty
  3. Carefully strain into your glass
  4. Garnish with lemon zest

Dan’s top tips

Some may find the fresh lemon juice in this drink too bitter and too bright, and that’s okay. Our version of the Lost Plane includes sugar syrup – the original has none – to help balance it all out. If you feel the need to tweak further, by all means go right ahead.

While we’re on the subject of tweaking to taste, consider swapping the lemon for fresh lime juice. It’s a simple substitute that delivers remarkably different results.

Now, when it comes to choosing an amaro – the world really is your oyster. There are seemingly trillions of options out there and all differ in taste quite a bit (that's the beauty of amaro). We love our Lost Plane with Montenegro or Averna, but have a play with whatever you have on hand and see what suits.

image credits: Shelley Horan (photography), Bridget Wald (stylist).